This mandate sets a dangerous precedent. It will allow government
to dictate which religious beliefs are lawful and which are not. In a May 21
Editorial, The New York Sun contended “the Church is seeking shelter under both
the Constitution, which prohibits Congress from making any law prohibiting the
free exercise of religion, and a statute, the Religious Freedom Restoration
Act.” This Act was passed in 1993 – by an overwhelming voice vote in the House
and a 97-03 vote in the Senate – with the aim of protecting free exercise.
The Act requires strict scrutiny of laws, and prohibits the
government from substantially burdening “a person’s exercise of religion even
if the burden results from a rule of general applicability.”
It would seem as though, the case the Catholic Church has launched
against the government, has the potential to emerge as one of the great civil
rights lawsuits of our time. The implications are great, not only for Catholics,
but for all religious groups in this country.
In the wake of the Catholic lawsuits, leaders from a variety of
faith backgrounds, politicians and educators met last Thursday in Washington,
D.C. for the National Religious Freedom Conference. In attendance was former
Health and Human Services secretary, Michael Levitt. Levitt said of the
conference, “this is the uniting of the faith community to declare that we’re
going to fight back to defend religious freedom.”
The
conference outlined three major threats to religious freedom: The first is the
government mandate that religious institutions, such as hospitals and
universities, act contrary to their conscience by offering birth control
coverage to their employees.
The
second is what religious leaders say is a threat to the autonomy of religious
organizations to choose their own leaders.
The
third issue is religious principles in everyday life, like pharmacists who
object for moral reasons to carrying what believers equate to abortion-causing
drugs or religious student-groups being marginalized on school campuses.
One example of the latter is the fight at Vanderbilt University over its
non-discrimination policy, requiring student religious groups be open leadership
to anyone, even those who don't hold to their beliefs.
Like delegates at the conference, I am very uncomfortable about
government’s growing trend to marginalize religion in the marketplace. In a
major foreign policy address last December, before United Nations delegates,
Secretary of State Hillary Clinton identified
“deeply-held … religious beliefs” as among “the obstacles standing in
the way of protecting the human rights of LGBT people.” (LGBT – Lesbian, Gay,
Bisexual, Transgender)
This growing hostility is not American. The American founders
viewed churches as a central institution within American life. The founders saw
religion as providing the moral foundation of self-restraint and community
awareness for the success of self-government.
Churches have contributed to the success of America by encouraging
virtue. Research in Social Science has also shown that churches provide direct
and indirect economic and social benefits to communities. Churches provide community
volunteerism, education, civic skills-training and reduced levels of deviance.
In addition, churches encourage civility, instill hope contribute to the long-term health of communities. If it were not for churches, government would have to expand public funding to replace the community benefits that churches provide.
Be encouraged – the first intensive effort by the state to
eliminate Christian thought came after the burning of Rome during the reign of the
Emperor Nero in 64 C.E. Nero made the Christians the scapegoats for the
disaster, and they were savagely tortured and burned, at least in and around
Rome. Untold numbers of Christians died heroically for their faith. So
impressive were the many who died gladly for Christ that they were more than
replaced by new converts. The Christian writer Tertullian observed: “The blood
of the martyrs is seed.”
For this reason I am strong, and so should you. As a way of moving
forward, the National Religious Freedom Conference announced plans to create
religious freedom caucuses in every state, an effort designed to bridge the gap
between politics and religion. Remember, retreating is not an option.